歴史を面白く学ぶコテンラジオ (COTEN RADIO) · History
【67-6】最初の犠牲は対馬!ついに具体化するモンゴルの日本侵攻計画【COTEN RADIO モンゴル帝国襲来編6】
In 1274, the Mongol-Goryeo combined force finally launched its invasion of Japan, and the island of Tsushima—the first target—was defended by deputy military governor Sukekuni and roughly 300 fighters who were annihilated against a force numbering in the tens of thousands. The Kamakura shogunate had scrambled to prepare through land-registry orders, transfer bans, and debt forgiveness, but these measures exposed deep limits in its governance. It would ultimately resort to the unprecedented step of mobilizing warriors outside its own vassal network.
Listen to this episode Go to the show page
What this episode answers
What legal and institutional preparations did the Kamakura shogunate make against the Mongol invasion?
The shogunate implemented three measures—submission of Otabumi land registries, a ban on transferring shogun-granted land, and an edict allowing gokenin to reclaim land lost to debt (effectively sanctioning debt default)—but investigation revealed massive gaps between records and reality, and the orders were more declaratory than enforceable, reflecting the shogunate's weak governance.
How do the conventional and revisionist accounts differ on Mongol troop strength and invasion routes?
The conventional account places the invasion force at 20,000 Mongol troops, more than 10,000 Korean troops, and 900 warships, while Kyushu University's Professor Hattori argues the true number was closer to 10,000—the same scale used in a later pacification campaign—a nearly threefold discrepancy in total strength.
How did the battle of Tsushima unfold, and what was its outcome?
The combined force left Happo on the Korean peninsula and reached Tsushima in a single day; deputy military governor Sukekuni led roughly 100 cavalry (about 300 fighters including infantry) in fierce resistance, but they were annihilated, Sasuura was burned, and Nichiren's letters record that women had holes pierced through their hands and were tied to the ships with rope—though that account is second-hand and its accuracy is uncertain.
What historical significance did the shogunate's order mobilizing non-gokenin warriors carry?
By ordering non-gokenin warriors to fight, the shogunate created a channel through which those who distinguished themselves could be granted gokenin status as reward, giving it a mechanism to absorb fighters previously outside its lord-vassal network and accelerating its centralization.
How is the conventional account that Japan 'won thanks to the divine wind' evaluated today?
Virtually every historian today rejects it; the divine-wind (typhoon) narrative is described as the single greatest revision to conventional history, and what actually decided the battle's outcome is the central question the revisionist account seeks to answer.
The Shogunate's Defense Preparations—From Land Registries to Debt Forgiveness
After the Mongols (Yuan dynasty) completed their grip on Goryeo, they set the invasion date in July 1274. The actual landing came three months later, in October. Having steeled itself for war after receiving a second, more belligerent letter from Kublai Khan, the Kamakura shogunate had already set preparations in motion.
Three specific measures were taken. First, it ordered the submission of **Otabumi (大田文)**, land registries documenting who held which plots and in what amounts. When investigators checked these records against reality, they found enormous discrepancies: estates had been subdivided among brothers through inheritance, and some nominal gokenin had effectively ceased to be gokenin after pledging or selling their land. Second, the shogunate banned further sale or transfer of land originally granted as a reward from the shogun. Third, it issued an edict allowing gokenin to reclaim land forfeited to pay debts—effectively authorizing debt default.
None of these measures carried real teeth. As historian Fukai observed, "governance was completely dysfunctional." Some gokenin heeded the orders; others ignored them, especially the further they were from Kamakura. These edicts were less law than proclamation.
Conventional vs. Revisionist History—Troop Numbers and the "Divine Wind"
Two competing accounts of the invasion exist. The conventional account puts Mongol forces at 20,000, Korean forces at more than 10,000, and the fleet at 900 warships. Professor Hattori of Kyushu University, however, argues the true figure was closer to 10,000—matching the scale of a force used in a later pacification campaign—a nearly threefold difference.
The single biggest revision concerns the **divine wind (kamikaze)**. The story that a typhoon destroyed the Mongol fleet and saved Japan appears in junior-high school textbooks, but virtually every historian today rejects it. What actually determined the outcome is the central question of this episode.
The First to Fall: Tsushima
The Mongol-Goryeo combined force left Happo (합포) on the southern tip of the Korean peninsula and **reached Tsushima in a single day**—roughly 80 kilometers away, only 50 kilometers from the peninsula's tip.
Tsushima was under the jurisdiction of the Shōni (少弐) clan, but the island's actual defense fell to the deputy military governor, **Sukekuni (助国)**. He commanded roughly 100 cavalry—around **300 fighters in total** including infantry—against a force numbering in the tens of thousands (at minimum 10,000 even in the revisionist account). They fought valiantly and were annihilated. The podcast compared them to "Leonidas and his 300 Spartans."
The Yuan forces burned Sasuura. Nichiren's letters record that women were gathered, had holes pierced through their hands, were strung on rope, and tied to the ships—though this is second-hand information and its accuracy remains uncertain. The opening sequence of the video game *Ghost of Tsushima* depicts this battle, showing the Mongol fleet crashing onto the shore.
Professor Hattori also notes that many Tsushima residents had long-standing ties with Goryeo, and whether island-wide intense fighting actually took place is debatable.
From Iki to Hakata Bay—An Unprecedented Call to Arms
Using Tsushima as a supply base, the Yuan forces spent roughly a week pushing on to **Iki**, where similar tragedy unfolded. In Hakata Bay, Kyushu gokenin detected the approaching fleet by the **large quantities of horse manure floating in the water**—the Mongols had transported horses by ship. (A historical scroll also confirms that Mongol cavalry horses had their tails wrapped and tied, apparently to keep them clean during the voyage.)
Upon receiving this report, the shogunate issued an extraordinary order: **all warriors—not just gokenin—were to fight**. In Hizen Province (roughly present-day Saga and Nagasaki), there were 279 warrior households, but only 72—about one-quarter—held formal vassal ties to the shogunate. The remaining three-quarters were ordinarily beyond its reach; the crisis was so severe that the shogunate appealed through nobles and religious institutions to bring them into the fight.
The long-term consequence was significant: warriors who distinguished themselves could be granted gokenin status as reward, giving the shogunate a mechanism to absorb fighters previously outside its lord-vassal network and deepen its centralization. It was through all of this that the Yuan-Goryeo combined forces finally landed at **Momochihara (百道原)** on the western shore of Hakata Bay.
Takeaways
- The Kamakura shogunate attempted three defensive measures—land-registry submission, transfer bans, and debt-forgiveness edicts—but weak enforcement revealed the fundamental limits of its governance.
- Tsushima's deputy military governor Sukekuni and his roughly 300 fighters were annihilated by the Mongol-Goryeo force, while the famous 'divine wind' narrative is now rejected by virtually all historians.
- The shogunate's unprecedented order mobilizing non-gokenin warriors became a turning point that allowed it to absorb fighters beyond its traditional vassal network and push toward greater centralization.
This article is edited from a machine transcript of the first 30 minutes of the episode. It is not an official summary — please listen to the episode itself.